| Common name | Species |
| Spotted Salamander | Ambystoma maculatum |
| Wood Frog | Rana sylvatica |
| Spring Peeper | Pseudacris crucifer |
| Jefferson Salamander | Ambystoma jeffersonianum |
| Blue-spotted Salamander | Ambystoma laterale |
| Red-spotted Newt | Notophthalam us viridescens |
| Redback salamander | Plethodon cinereus |
| Four-toed Salamander | Hemidactylium scutatum |
| Northern Red Salamander | Pseudotriton ruber ruber |
| Bullfrog | Rana catesbeiana |
| Green Frog | Rana clamitans melanota |
| Pickerel Frog | Rana palustris |
| Leopard Frog | Rana pipiens |
| Gray Treefrog | Hyla versicolor |
| American Toad | Bufo americanus |
| Eastern Box Turtle | Terrapene carolina carolina |
| Midland Painted Turtle | Chrysemys picta marginata |
| Snapping Turtle | Chelydra serpentin |
| Common Musk Turtle | Sternotherus odoratus |
| Northern Water Snake | Nerodia sipedon sipedon |
| Northern Ring-necked Snake | Diadophis punctatus edwardsii |
| Eastern Garter Snake | Thamnophis sirtalis sirtalis |
| Eastern Ribbon Snake | Thamnophis sauritus |
| Eastern Smooth Green Snake | Opheodrys vernalis vernalis |
| Black Racer | Coluber constrictor |
Contributors: Peter Niewiarowski, Mindy Thomson